I’m not entirely sure how I feel about Occupy Wall Street in its Canadian incarnation.
I mean, average people who don’t usually pay attention to the news, have probably heard of Occupy Wall Street. People want to know what it is, how they’re affected, if it’s a justifiable cause. Hundreds of people have written their stories on pieces of paper and taken pictures alongside them with their webcams. People are sick and tired of being sick and tired, they’re tired of being taken advantage of, they’re tired of getting poorer while the rich get richer. For this, the purpose of Occupy Wall Street is very real. A lot of people have been fucked over by corporate greed and irresponsible government, and I totally support those people. I understand what they’re mad, and I’m proud of my brethren to the south for finally standing up to something that came to a massive head at the end of the previous president’s term. Inspired by the Arab spring, people of the richest nation in the world are speaking out about the inequities and injustices of how money works in the US.
I completely understand why people in the US are mad, and it’s not like class or wealth disparities and irresponsible corporations don’t exist in Canada. But we do have free healthcare. We have unemployment insurance, welfare, disability, CSST, cheaper tuition (especially compared to the U.S.); in Quebec, we have the Regie de logement, and it’s illegal for landlords to ask for first and last, or even a deposit. There are programs in place to help people who can’t always be self-sufficient.
This isn’t to say there aren’t problems here. There are still poor people Canada. People are broke. Student loans suck, people have to live in shitty apartments with bed bugs and cockroaches. Welfare doesn’t pay out enough. My parents are still living paycheque to paycheque and my dad doesn’t have any kind of pension or retirement plan. The future looks grim as the population ages and the young people are asked to support more than just themselves. But.
People in the US can’t even go to the doctor when their kids are sick because it’s so expensive. A woman I met in San Francisco pays $500 a month to sleep in what used to be a walk-in closet. My old (American) roommate owes upwards of $40,000 to Fannie Mae for her education—and that’s for having studied in Montreal.
Some Americans decry government programs because they think they infringe on their freedom. So, congratulations, then—you have the freedom to be impossibly broke. When you get cancer, you’ll be bankrupted by chemo treatments. When your kids grow up, they won’t be able to afford to go to college. When you lose your job, you’ll also lose your house and car. Where’s the pride in that?
Canadians face those problems too, but it just feels as though it’s to a lesser degree. Here in Montreal, you can be a student who works 15 hours a week and afford a tiny room in a tiny apartment and go out with friends on weekends. You can be a welfare parent and take your kids to the doctor whenever they get sick AND get them medication, without having to worry whether enough will be left over for groceries.
As the crazy old lady I spoke to on the phone last night said, people act so entitled to everything, and despite the fact that I disagreed with 99 per cent of everything else she said to me, I can’t help but find a grain of truth in that. You can’t have the government give you everything you need and want—that’s unfeasible.
All this to say, I’m not sure the message is getting across in Canada. If the local Occupy movements are simply just shows of solidarity for Occupy Wall Street, that’s one thing. But at least here in Montreal, people are talking about local problems. Which is, you know, fine. People do it all the time here. There’s a protest a day in this city, so the more the merrier. We certainly have our share of problems in the city, that are different from Toronto’s problems, that are different from Vancouver’s problems. We’ve all got our own local problems with economic inequality and getting dicked around by the system. I do. You do.
But for the larger message of Occupy Wall Street—that 1 per cent of the population has 99 per cent of the nation’s wealth: the 1 per cent have 99 per cent of the wealth because Americans gave it to them. They wouldn’t be in business if no one purchased anything from them, after all. And so the most important thing you can do is stop giving your hard-earned money to the 1 per cent. As long as occupiers have iPhones and $5 lattes at Starbucks, no real and honest lesson is being taught (or learned) here. If they stop feeding the 1 per cent their money, they won’t be able to stay in business. It’s not like the government’s going to shut down Bank of America anytime soon, or that Wal-Mart’s going to close up shop because they suddenly realize the damage they’re causing.
Outside of actual elections, the most important vote you can cast is with your hard-earned cash, so be wise with where you spend it.
More reading:
http://www.theglobeandmail.com/news/opinions/writer-allan-fotheringham-on-the-occupy-wall-street-movement/article2207089/